Income School Project 24 review: what it costs, what the guarantee really covers, and what members and critics say
Project 24 is the paid membership sold by Income School, the Idaho company behind the Income School YouTube channel. It started as a niche-blogging course and is now sold mainly as a YouTube growth system, with blogging, community, podcast and mastermind access included. We read the sales page, refund policy, terms of service, challenge and affiliate pages, the BBB profile and its complaint, Trustpilot, the Reddit threads that rank on Google, and two reviewer videos with their comments.

Our verdict (editorial opinion)
A real, long-running and relatively cheap membership with a fair refund window, but recent independent evidence that the method still works is thin. Project 24 costs $499 for the first year and $299 for each renewal, according to the sales page. You can get a full refund within 7 days, and a renewal fee back if you ask in writing within 30 days of being charged. The “monetized within 50 videos” guarantee comes with conditions set out in the terms. BBB rates Income School LLC A+ with one complaint in three years. The criticism is about results: Reddit threads that rank on Google, and a 2025 Trustpilot review, say the niche-site method stopped working for many members after Google’s 2023 updates. Those are users’ accounts, and we found no independent data on typical member results.
Last verified: 19 November 2026 · Research-based review · Prices, terms and community counts are as shown on the cited pages on that date
The short version
- Who sells it: Income School LLC, an Idaho limited liability company. Its terms of service (last updated 25 March 2026) give a Meridian, Idaho address and choose Idaho law and the courts of Ada County. Co-founder Ricky Kesler now runs it; co-founder Jim Harmer left in 2021.
- What you get: the “YouTube System” course, blogging and other courses, a members’ community, a members’ podcast, live group masterminds, tools and templates, and monthly challenges. It is not one-to-one mentoring. The sales page says most answers in the community come from other members.
- Price (19 Nov 2026): $499 for the first year, then $299 a year, renewing automatically until you cancel. A “P24 Bundle” with the monthly challenges is $599 for the first year and $399 a year after (challenges page).
- Refunds: full refund within 7 days of signing up, no questions required. You can also get a renewal fee back if you ask in writing within 30 days of the renewal date. There are no partial refunds if you cancel mid-term (refund policy).
- Guarantee: the sales page says that if your channel isn’t monetized by your 50th video, Income School will work with you “individually” or “refund your entire cost”. The terms add conditions, and say the refund covers your dues “for the duration of the time you were working on your YouTube channel”.
- BBB: Income School LLC is rated A+ (not accredited). It has one complaint in the last three years, from April 2024. The company first refused a $499 refund and then issued one.
- Trustpilot: incomeschool.com is an unclaimed profile with just 3 reviews (3.1). That is too few to tell you much.
- Reddit on Google: a negative r/SEO thread, “Income School Is Now as Bad as Neil Patel” (January 2024, 151 comments), ranks #5 for the bare name “income school”. For “project 24 reviews” and “income school reviews” the top Reddit results are older, mixed threads. A negative 2024 thread ranks #8 for “project 24 review” and #3 for “is project 24 worth it”.
- Regulators and courts: no FTC or state attorney-general action found, and no cases naming Income School LLC in CourtListener’s federal archive.
Is Project 24 legit?
Yes, in the sense that it is a real course sold by a real company with published terms. Income School LLC has been in business since January 2015, according to BBB. It publishes its price, a written refund policy and full terms of service, and its BBB file shows one complaint in three years. The free YouTube channel has been running for years, and both reviewer videos we watched, plus several Reddit commenters, credit the free and paid material with teaching them keyword research and article planning.
The open question is whether the method still works. Project 24 became known for a “publish lots of helpful articles, skip link building” approach to niche sites. In 2024 Reddit threads, members and former followers say their sites lost most of their traffic after Google’s 2023 ranking updates, and that Income School did not deal with this openly. Income School now sells Project 24 mainly as a YouTube course, with a monetization guarantee. We have no independent data on how many members succeed under either approach.
Is Project 24 a scam? We don’t use that word. Below we set out what Income School’s own pages and terms say, what members and critics report, the company’s side, and the public record, with links.
Who runs it
Income School was started by Ricky Kesler and Jim Harmer, who say on their about page that they were friends from high school and began with a podcast before building niche sites and a YouTube channel. In an August 2021 Niche Pursuits interview, Kesler announced that Harmer was leaving and that Kesler was taking over full ownership of Income School, including Project 24 and the YouTube channel. Harmer’s LinkedIn profile says he sold his interest and now focuses on his firearms brand Backfire and a private school in Utah. The current about page lists Ricky Kesler, Cody Lockwood, Nathan and Julia Minor as the team.
BBB lists Frederick J Kesler as the company’s member and principal contact. The company gives slightly different locations in different places: the terms describe it as “located in Star, Idaho” but give a mailing address in Meridian, BBB lists a different Meridian address, and Trustpilot’s unclaimed listing shows Caldwell, Idaho. All three towns are in the Boise area.
The about page lists niche sites the founders built and mostly sold, including Camper Report (“almost $10,000 per month”), Pontoon Guide (“over $4,000 per month”) and Dirt Bike Planet (“almost $2,000 per month”). Those figures are the seller’s own, and we have not verified them. Several Reddit commenters in 2024 said these sites had since lost traffic. We did not check that either.
What you get, according to the seller
The Project 24 sales page lists:
- YouTube System: a course on channel topics, video types, titles, thumbnails and growth. Older reviewers say this part was built with Nate Black of Channel Makers.
- Community: a members’ forum the page calls a “24/7 helpline”. The page also says Project 24 is not individual mentorship and that most answers come from other members.
- Masterminds, a members’ podcast, custom tools and templates.
- Other courses: monetization, social media, brand building, email marketing and blogging.
- Challenges: monthly skill challenges, sold separately or as part of the P24 Bundle.
The page shows testimonials from members, including channels with large subscriber counts, and says “Our members rate us 5 out of 5!”. Those are the seller’s selected reviews.
About the results on this page. Subscriber counts, income figures and site earnings attributed to Income School or its members are their own claims, taken from the seller’s pages or from reviewers. We have not verified them. Income School’s own terms say Project 24 is “not a promise or guarantee of business or financial success” and that “not all Project 24 members succeed”.
What it costs
| Option | Price (19 Nov 2026) | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Project 24, first year | $499 | Sales page FAQ |
| Project 24, each renewal year | $299, renewing automatically until cancelled | Sales page FAQ, terms |
| P24 Bundle (Project 24 + monthly challenges) | $599 first year; $399 a year after | Challenges page |
| Monthly challenges only | $19 a month or $190 a year (the same page also shows “$27 per month”) | Challenges page |
| Earlier prices reported by users | $449 first year, then $249–$250 a year (2022) | 2022 reviewer video, r/NewTubers |
Project 24 is named after a 24-month goal, while the price covers 12 months. One YouTube commenter argued the first-year fee should cover the full 24 months. Income School’s FAQ says the name refers to a goal “and not a promise or guarantee” of success in that time.
The fine print: refunds, the guarantee and the rules
These points come from Income School’s refund policy and terms of service (last updated 25 March 2026).
- 7-day money-back guarantee: if Project 24 isn’t a good fit within 7 days of registering, a support ticket gets a full refund, and the refund does not depend on answering feedback questions. The same 7 days apply to stand-alone courses.
- Renewals: the 7-day policy also applies to renewals. If you forget to cancel before a renewal, Income School says it will cancel and refund the renewal fee if you ask in writing within 30 days. The terms add that it is your responsibility to cancel and that Income School “will not cancel your account for you”.
- No partial refunds if you cancel during a paid term. You keep access until the term ends.
- “Monetized Within 50 Videos” guarantee: all 50 videos must be published while you are a member, and you must follow the Project 24 guidance. You must ask the community and an Income School team member for help and let them review your channel. YouTube must have turned you down only on subscriber count and watch hours. If you meet all of that and “wish to abandon the project rather than accept personalized help”, Income School will refund your membership dues for the time you were working on the channel.
- Rules and termination: sharing course material or community posts outside Project 24, posting screenshots of course or forum material, spamming members, or creating a “nuisance” can get you removed “without a refund”.
- Your content and likeness: by joining you agree that Income School can use your name, words, voice and likeness, including from recorded calls, for promotion without paying you.
- Liability and disputes: liability is capped at what you paid. Idaho law applies, disputes go to the courts of Ada County or the federal court in Idaho, and the winning side can recover attorney’s fees.
Compared with many programs we review, these refund terms are generous: a no-questions 7-day window and a 30-day window for missed renewals. The 50-video guarantee is narrower than the sales-page headline suggests. Before relying on it, read the conditions in the terms.
Regulators and court records
- BBB: Income School LLC, 4664 N Penngrove Way, Meridian, Idaho, is rated A+, is not accredited, has a file opened 8 November 2021 and lists a business start date of 7 January 2015. It shows one complaint in the last three years and none in the last 12 months. We describe the complaint below.
- Courts: a CourtListener search for “Income School LLC” returned no federal dockets or opinions on 19 November 2026. State courts were not searched.
- Regulators: we found no FTC or state attorney-general action naming Income School or Project 24 in web searches.
What members and critics say
About the allegations on this page. Statements from Reddit, Trustpilot or YouTube users are their own opinions or accounts. We quote or summarise them with a link and date; we have not verified them, and we do not present them as fact.
BBB complaint (April 2024)
The one published complaint (12 April 2024, “Answered”) is from a buyer who says they paid $499. The buyer says the chat help on the site did not work the first two times they tried it and that a refund request was refused two days later. The company replied that the chatbot is a new feature for all site visitors, not a membership feature, and that members get support by email, ticket and the community. It said it was enforcing the refund policy the buyer agreed to, and it described the buyer’s later emails and social-media posts as harassment. The buyer rejected that response, and the company then wrote that it had “decided to issue a full refund despite our policy”. The complaint does not say how many days after purchase the refund was requested.
Trustpilot
Trustpilot’s profile for incomeschool.com is unclaimed and shows 3 reviews with a 3.1 score. Trustpilot’s panel says the company has no history of asking for reviews, “so reviews may not be representative”. Two reviews are short five-star posts from 2019 and 2022. The newest, from March 2025 and titled “Used to be good” (2 stars), is from someone who says they were a member for three years. They say the material “worked well in the past” but no longer works “like it used to”, and claim that Income School hasn’t owned a successful website since 2020. That claim is the reviewer’s, and we have not verified it.
We ran 12 natural Google searches (US, English, desktop, 19 November 2026), including “project 24”, “project 24 reviews”, “project 24 review”, “income school”, “income school reviews”, “income school review”, “is project 24 worth it”, “ricky kesler” and “ricky kesler reviews”. The bare term “project 24” returns unrelated businesses and no Reddit thread on page 1. The threads that did rank, and the ones we read, are below.
| Thread | Google position (query) | Overall sentiment | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| r/SEO “Income School Is Now as Bad as Neil Patel” (Jan 2024, 151 comments) | #5 (income school) | Negative | The poster says Income School’s “entire clientele has been decimated” by Google’s helpful content update and that it doesn’t acknowledge this. Several replies agree, and some say critical comments on the channel were deleted (unverified). Others, including a member, say the method worked well for years and that Google moved the goalposts, “not their fault”. |
| r/SEO “Incomeschool aka Project 24, is it any good?” (Jan 2024, 17 comments) | #3 (is project 24 worth it); #8 (project 24 review) | Negative | A prospective buyer asks about members hit by the update. The top reply, from someone who says they just unsubscribed, says the course hadn’t changed in five years and that critics get banned from the forum. Others call it outdated. One commenter calls Income School a reasonable YouTube resource that hasn’t kept up with recent updates. |
| r/Blogging “Anyone have experience with Income School Project 24?” (Jun 2021, 9 comments) | #1 (project 24 reviews, project 24 review); #3 (income school review); #6 (income school reviews) | Mixed | One commenter says the course “was fine” for beginners but the community felt like “an echo chamber”. Others suggest the free YouTube videos cover most of it. |
| r/Blogging “How many of you follow Income School?” (May 2021, 21 comments) | #3 (income school reviews) | Mixed | One commenter who took the course says it does “a very good job” for beginners but isn’t “revolutionary”; another who has it says it’s good but the community is full of “one dimensional thinkers”. Another says it changed how they do keyword research, and others say the free content is enough. |
| r/NewTubers “Project 24 – YouTube Course” (Mar 2022, 17 comments) | #1 (project 24 youtube system review) | Negative-leaning | Most replies call the then $449-a-year price too high and say free YouTube channels teach the same thing. One buyer says they liked the videos but weren’t “seeing” the value. One commenter defends it as a broader blogging, affiliate and YouTube program. |
Does a negative Reddit thread rank on Google page 1? For the bare company name “income school”, yes: the January 2024 r/SEO thread is #5. For the bare course name “project 24”, no. For “project 24 reviews” and “income school reviews”, the Reddit threads on page 1 are mixed rather than negative. A negative thread does rank #8 for “project 24 review” and #3 for “is project 24 worth it”. No Reddit thread ranked for “ricky kesler” or “ricky kesler reviews”.
For context, Google’s own list of ranking updates includes the September 2023 helpful content update and the March 2024 core update, which many Reddit commenters blame for their traffic losses. We can’t tell from public data how many Project 24 members were affected.
YouTube
- “Income School Project 24 Review 2022 – BRUTALLY Honest” by Aidan Lehane (June 2022, about 2,800 views) calls the course worth buying “for the community alone”. He says he used it to grow a golf site to about “40 grand per month” (currency not stated), a figure we can’t verify. His criticisms: Income School’s focus had shifted to YouTube; buyers can’t easily tell how many large sites the founders still own; and the affiliate-marketing training is weaker than other courses. He sells his own course from the video description. One commenter pointed out that the price in his description, in the video and on his linked page didn’t match. Another said Harmer had left and Kesler was now running the company.
- “Income Schools Project 24 (Honest) Review: Legit or Scam” by Fehed Nicass (February 2022, about 1,000 views) praises the community, the number of courses and the search-analysis training, and calls the course “definitely not a scam”. He rates it nine out of ten. His main complaint is the yearly fee, then about $449 and $249, which he would rather see replaced by a one-time price. He says his own first site earns some income but not a salary.
- Both videos are from 2022, before the 2023–2024 Google updates that later critics focus on. We found no recent independent video review with a detailed member account.
Income School’s side
- It doesn’t promise results. The sales page and terms say Project 24 is “not a guarantee of success–especially not in any particular time-frame”, that a business needs “skill, hard work, and time”, and that “not all Project 24 members succeed”.
- It is upfront that this is not mentorship. The FAQ says most help comes from other members and that staff spend most of their time making resources for everyone.
- The refund terms are clear and fairly generous. There is a 7-day no-questions refund, a 30-day refund for forgotten renewals, and the 50-video guarantee for YouTube members who meet its conditions.
- On the BBB complaint, the company explained its policy and the chatbot’s purpose, and then refunded the buyer.
- It warns about impersonators. Its promotional policy says dozens of people a month use Income School’s name or images to market products it does not endorse.
- Affiliate reviews: Income School pays affiliates 10% (“usually about $50”) and up to 20% (about $100) per Project 24 referral (affiliate page). Many “Project 24 review” pages online earn that commission. We don’t.
- We did not find a public response from Income School to the 2024 Reddit criticism about the effect of Google’s updates on members’ sites.
How we counted the evidence
| Source | Positive | Negative / complaint | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seller pages and terms | Published price; 7-day refund; renewal refund; “no guarantee” disclaimers | Guarantee conditions narrower than the headline; no partial refunds; broad likeness release | Results and testimonials are the seller’s |
| BBB | A+ rating; 1 complaint in 3 years, answered and refunded | Refund first refused (April 2024) | Not accredited |
| Trustpilot (3 reviews) | Two short 5-star reviews (2019, 2022) | One 2-star (2025): “used to be good” | Unclaimed; too few to judge |
| Reddit (5 threads, 79 comments read) | Members who say it worked for years or taught them keyword research | Method outdated after Google updates; price; moderation claims | Two negative threads rank on page 1; the top review-query threads are mixed |
| YouTube (2 videos, 12 comments) | Both reviewers recommend it | Yearly fee; shift to YouTube | Both from 2022; one reviewer sells his own course |
| Courts and regulators | — | — | Nothing found |
Our verdict
Mixed evidence. Project 24 is a real, long-running membership from a company with a clean BBB record and refund terms that are fairer than most in this space. At $499 for the first year, it is also far cheaper than the high-ticket coaching we usually review. The problem is the evidence on results. The most detailed independent accounts we found either date from 2021–2022, when the blogging method was widely praised, or from 2024, when members and former followers said Google’s updates wiped out sites built that way. We found no independent data on how members do with the YouTube System or the 50-video guarantee.
It may suit you if: you are a beginner who wants a structured course and a community, you are willing to work for a year or more with no guaranteed income, and you will use the 7-day refund window to check the material. Be careful if: you are buying mainly for niche-site blogging traffic from Google, you expect one-to-one coaching, or you are counting on the guarantee without reading its conditions.
Before you pay: watch the free Income School YouTube videos first, since several buyers say they cover much of the method. Put a calendar reminder 5 days after you join and before each renewal. Read the “Monetized Within 50 Videos” terms if that guarantee is why you are buying.
Not enough third-party information on results
We found no independent data on how many Project 24 members reach the “pizza day” or full-time-income badges, how many YouTube members reach monetization within 50 videos, or how many refund or guarantee claims are made and paid. Testimonials come from the seller, the two reviewer videos are from 2022, and the Reddit accounts on both sides are anonymous and unverified. A fair verdict on results would need member outcome data published or verified by someone other than Income School.
What we like
- Real company since 2015 with published price and terms
- No-questions 7-day refund and 30-day refund for forgotten renewals
- BBB A+, one complaint in three years (refunded)
- Much cheaper than most programs we review
What to watch out for
- Recent Reddit and Trustpilot accounts say the niche-site method stopped working after Google’s 2023–2024 updates (unverified)
- The 50-video guarantee carries several conditions and covers dues for the time worked, not automatically the full cost
- Little recent independent evidence on member results
- Auto-renews yearly; not one-to-one mentoring
Corrections and right of reply. If you are Ricky Kesler or represent Income School LLC or represent the seller, or you think anything here is wrong or out of date, email hello@active-learning-site.com with the page and a source. We will check it, correct the page if needed and publish a factual response from the seller.
Alternatives
- Another long-running, low-cost affiliate and website-building membership with many affiliate reviews: our Wealthy Affiliate review.
- A YouTube course with a published price and conflicting refund terms: our Matt Par Tube Mastery review.
- A higher-priced faceless-YouTube coaching programme with a strict no-refund policy: our WannerCashCow review.
- More programmes: creator course reviews.
Project 24 FAQ
How much does Project 24 cost?
On 19 November 2026 the sales page listed $499 for the first year and $299 for each year after, renewing automatically until you cancel. The P24 Bundle, which adds monthly challenges, is $599 for the first year and $399 a year after.
Can I get a refund from Project 24?
Yes, within 7 days of signing up, with no questions required. If you forget to cancel before a renewal, Income School says it will refund the renewal fee if you ask in writing within 30 days. It gives no partial refunds for cancelling mid-term.
What is the Project 24 50-video guarantee?
The sales page says that if your channel isn’t monetized by the time you publish 50 videos, Income School will work with you individually or refund you. The terms add conditions: all 50 videos made while a member, following the course, asking the community and staff for help, and being turned down by YouTube only on subscribers and watch hours. The refund covers your dues for the time you worked on the channel.
Is Project 24 still worth it?
It depends on what you want from it. It is cheaper than most programs and has a fair refund window. But several 2024 Reddit threads and a 2025 Trustpilot review say the niche-blogging method stopped working for many members after Google’s updates, and we found no independent data on current member results.
Who owns Income School?
Ricky Kesler. Co-founder Jim Harmer left in August 2021, when Kesler took over full ownership, according to a Niche Pursuits interview. BBB lists Frederick J Kesler as the LLC’s member.
Does a negative Reddit thread rank on Google for Project 24?
For the bare name “income school”, a negative January 2024 r/SEO thread ranks #5. For “project 24” there is no Reddit result on page 1, and for “project 24 reviews” the top Reddit thread is mixed. A negative 2024 thread ranks #8 for “project 24 review” and #3 for “is project 24 worth it”.
Sources and last verified
Last verified: 19 November 2026. Seller pages, terms, BBB, Trustpilot and community sources were read on that date; member and reviewer accounts are their own and unverified. Google US page-1 rankings for 12 brand and review queries were captured with the Google Search scraper on the same date.
- Project 24 sales page (seller) — price FAQ, guarantee and contents read 19 Nov 2026
- Income School homepage (seller) — read 19 Nov 2026
- Refund policy (seller) — read 19 Nov 2026
- Terms of Service, last updated 25 Mar 2026 (seller) — read 19 Nov 2026
- Challenges and P24 Bundle pricing (seller) — read 19 Nov 2026
- About Income School (seller) — read 19 Nov 2026
- Affiliate information (seller) — read 19 Nov 2026
- Niche Pursuits: interview with Ricky Kesler — 18 Aug 2021; read 19 Nov 2026
- Jim Harmer LinkedIn profile — read 19 Nov 2026
- BBB: Income School LLC, Meridian ID — profile read 19 Nov 2026
- BBB complaints: Income School LLC — 1 complaint (12 Apr 2024) read 19 Nov 2026
- Trustpilot: incomeschool.com — 3 reviews, 3.1, unclaimed; read 19 Nov 2026
- Reddit r/SEO 194psku — post and 25 of 151 comments read 19 Nov 2026
- Reddit r/SEO 1abob1a — post and 16 comments read 19 Nov 2026
- Reddit r/Blogging o8ges3 — post and 6 comments read 19 Nov 2026
- Reddit r/Blogging nbf1kr — post and 17 comments read 19 Nov 2026
- Reddit r/NewTubers tgf1rn — post and 15 comments read 19 Nov 2026
- YouTube: Aidan Lehane, Project 24 review (2022) — transcript and comments read 19 Nov 2026; reviewer sells his own course
- YouTube: Fehed Nicass, Project 24 review (2022) — transcript and comments read 19 Nov 2026
- Google Search Central: ranking updates — read 19 Nov 2026
- CourtListener search: “Income School LLC” — no results, 19 Nov 2026
Reader comments
Comments are from readers and are not verified by us. If you actually bought or took this course, tell us about your first-hand experience — it helps other readers and may be cited in updates to this review.
No approved comments yet. Be the first to share your experience.